Thursday, July 17, 2008

on subtle failure

While reading through the top links on proggit, I ran into a project I'd seen a long while ago and promised myself I'd keep track of.  I didn't.  But this story isn't about me and my need for a simple bookmarking/reminder service, and the ways in which such a thing could change how I keep track of interesting things on the web.  That story will come later.  No this story is about the clutter project, the project I had accidentally lost track of.

From reading their very dark website, you'll discover that clutter is YAGUIWT(Yet Another GUI Widget Toolkit). What makes it special? It's cross platform-ish, has bindings to a ton of languages, and supposedly doesn't bring the cruft that most of the well known toolkits have grown to contain. Despite being a bit dark, and being quite a visual shift from reddit's simple blue on white look, it's a visually appealing site that has the touches of professional design. It was easy to get my bearings on the site and find information about the project and things of interest, save for one little subtle thing. Screenshots.

Again, the clutter project, is a GUI/Widget toolkit, a graphical tool to make your applications usable by the masses. A tool that claims to work across several platforms, and languages. But most importantly, it's end result is a visible GUI application. I thought at first that I was just missing the link to the screenshots. They have to be there. Maybe they're just not linked off of one of the top pages. Who would make a well designed, and informative web page about a GUI/Widget toolkit, and not put up any screenshots? So, being the resourceful individual that I am, I moved on to the omnipresent google. This search should return all the instances of the word screenshot on their site. That's bound to turn up these hidden screenshots. Except it doesn't.

Failing to put up screenshots has obviously not caused the death of the project. But it's still a failure. A subtle failure, but a failure nonetheless. They've failed at managing their user's expectations. They've failed by forcing me to go hunt for information, that should be clearly displayed on their site. Or at the very least made it known that the information wasn't provided by the site. Despite failing to provide me with information I think is pertinent, as a programmer I'm still very intrigued by their product.

The time I spent hunting for the missing screenshots (and subsequently writing this post) should have been spent reading the API docs, or downloading the source, or installing a binary package, or a sample application, or any other activity that could lead to me becoming an active user, contributor, or at the least a vocal supporter. Instead I'll add the project back to my mental (or conveniently web based, and amazingly intuitive, and hopefully soon to be released) list of things to check back on when I have time. Odds are good that like the last time, I won't.

Labels:

8 Comments:

Blogger ninternity© said...

There were a couple of screenshots from Moblin shown on this post:
http://www.clutter-project.org/blog/?p=58

July 17, 2008  
Blogger David Avraamides said...

I don't think you tried very hard. If you go to Clutter's home page (which you link to) it has a link to the Clutter blog near the bottom of the page which says "Visit the clutter blog for the latest Clutter news, developments, screen shots, screen casts and more."

Maybe it's just because you misspelled screen shot in your search?

July 17, 2008  
Blogger pTymN said...

Thank you. I was just looking at the website and wondering where the screenshots are.

July 17, 2008  
Blogger Shandra said...

My thoughts exactly.

July 17, 2008  
Blogger Tanner Burson said...

@ninternity

I saw the link in that post, but it gave me the distinct impression that it was screenshots of another group's project based on clutter. While this is certainly a useful bit of information, it still doesn't compare to how other similar projects handle this, such as http://fox-toolkit.org or http://fltk.org.

July 17, 2008  
Blogger Tanner Burson said...

@david

If i misspelled screenshot please show me the alternative spelling that would have yielded me links to screenshots for the project. Also, the only screenshot I found on the first massive page of the blog was the one ninternity pointed out above, which is a screenshot of a different project, which uses parts of clutter.

July 17, 2008  
Blogger Hector Villalobos said...

I feel the same way.

July 17, 2008  
Blogger cersibon said...

@david: Doesn't change the fact that you still have to, quite literally, hunt the blog for screenshots. It doesn't have a screenshots category, and, as of now, there are no screenshots on the blog's quite lengthy main page.

Result: to hell with this.

April 09, 2009  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home